South Africa's Edge: Is Collapse Imminent?

Watch the Episode

Video originally published on October 21, 2023.

In the heart of sub-Saharan Africa, a nation of profound historical significance and economic might stands at a precipice. South Africa, once a beacon of hope post-apartheid, now grapples with a multifaceted crisis that threatens to unravel its social fabric and economic stability. As power outages plague hospitals, crime rates surge, and corruption runs rampant, the question looms large: Is South Africa on the brink of collapse? The stakes are high, not just for the 60 million people who call it home, but for the entire region. The outcome will shape the geopolitical landscape, influencing everything from trade routes to security alliances. This is not a distant concern but an imminent challenge that demands urgent attention and strategic foresight.

Key Takeaways

South Africa's energy crisis began in the late 1990s when Eskom, the state-owned utility, warned of impending shortages due to aging infrastructure.
The energy crisis has led to chronic power outages, known as load shedding, which have crippled industries and fueled social unrest.
Corruption under President Jacob Zuma's tenure from 2009 to 2018 exacerbated the energy crisis, with Eskom becoming a hotbed of corrupt activities.
The energy crisis has catalyzed a surge in crime and social unrest, with statistics from the South African Police Service revealing a disturbing trend in the first quarter of 2023.
The African National Congress (ANC), led by President Cyril Ramaphosa, faces a challenging election in 2024, with its grip on power fading after poor performance in the 2021 municipal elections.
The potential collapse of South Africa's power grid and economy would send shockwaves through the region, exacerbating tensions and crises in neighboring countries like Mozambique and Zimbabwe.

South Africa's Tumultuous History: A Foundation for Fragility

South Africa's contemporary challenges are deeply rooted in its tumultuous history, marked by periods of colonial exploitation, racial segregation, and political upheaval. The legacy of apartheid, which lasted from 1948 to 1994, has left indelible marks on the nation's social, economic, and political landscape. The apartheid regime, led by the National Party, implemented a system of institutionalized racial segregation that marginalized the Black majority, allocating them to poverty-stricken townships and bantu states while the white minority enjoyed wealthy suburbs and urban centers. This deliberate impoverishment and disenfranchisement created deep-seated inequalities that persist to this day. The Soweto Uprising of 1976, where thousands of Black students protested against the imposition of Afrikaans as a medium of instruction, resulted in a violent crackdown by the South African Police, leaving hundreds dead. This event marked a turning point in the anti-apartheid movement, galvanizing international support and domestic resistance. The African National Congress (ANC), led by figures such as Nelson Mandela and Oliver Tambo, played a pivotal role in the struggle against apartheid. The ANC's armed wing, Umkhonto we Sizwe (MK), launched guerrilla attacks against government targets, seeking to destabilize the apartheid regime. Mandela's imprisonment in 1962 and his subsequent release in 1990 became symbolic of the struggle for freedom and equality. The ANC's rise to power in 1994, following Mandela's election as the country's first Black president, was a watershed moment. However, the transition from apartheid to democracy was fraught with challenges. The new government inherited an economy in shambles, with vast disparities in wealth and infrastructure. The ANC faced the daunting task of addressing the legacy of apartheid while navigating the complexities of a globalizing world. Initial efforts focused on redistributive policies, such as the Reconstruction and Development Programme (RDP), aimed at providing basic services to the marginalized. However, these initiatives often fell short due to corruption, mismanagement, and the sheer scale of the problems. The energy sector, for instance, was initially a bright spot. The apartheid regime's policy of self-sufficiency had resulted in an abundance of coal-fired power plants, enabling South Africa to electrify 2.5 million previously unserved households, predominantly Black. This surplus even allowed for the export of electricity to neighboring countries. However, the rapid industrialization and economic growth post-apartheid outpaced the development of energy infrastructure, leading to chronic shortages and blackouts. The state-owned utility, Eskom, became a symbol of the government's struggles, plagued by corruption, mismanagement, and a failure to maintain aging infrastructure. The legacy of apartheid and the subsequent challenges of post-apartheid reconstruction have created a fragile foundation for South Africa. The deep-seated inequalities, coupled with the pressures of rapid development and globalization, have left the country vulnerable to crises. The ANC's inability to effectively address these issues has led to a growing sense of disillusionment among the populace, fueling social unrest and political instability. As South Africa grapples with these historical legacies, the specter of collapse looms, threatening not only the country's future but also the stability of the broader region.

The Energy Crisis: A Catalyst for Chaos

South Africa's energy woes trace back to the late 1990s, when the state-owned utility Eskom began warning of impending shortages. Established in 1923, Eskom operates nearly all of South Africa's power plants and transmission facilities. By 1998, Eskom projected that without significant investment, the country would exhaust its electrical reserves by 2007. The utility's aging infrastructure, much of it dating back to the apartheid era, required substantial upgrades and expansion. However, the government hesitated, debating whether to privatize Eskom or maintain state control. This indecision allowed the crisis to escalate unchecked. The turning point came in 2007 when South Africa experienced its first major blackouts. The government, now acknowledging the severity of the situation, initiated a massive build program. However, corruption, mismanagement, and delays plagued these projects, leaving Eskom with insufficient capacity to meet growing demand. Enter load shedding, a term that has since become synonymous with South Africa's energy predicament. Load shedding involves deliberate, rotating power outages designed to prevent a total grid collapse. Initially implemented as an emergency measure, load shedding has become a regular feature of life in South Africa. The impact of load shedding on the economy and daily life is profound. In 2022, South Africans endured load shedding for over 200 days, with some households experiencing nearly half a day without electricity. The industrial sector, once a driving force of the South African economy, has been particularly hard hit. Factories operate on reduced schedules, leading to job losses and decreased productivity. The World Bank estimates that load shedding costs South Africa up to 2% of its GDP annually. Small businesses, which often lack backup power solutions, are also struggling to stay afloat. Load shedding disrupts operations, leads to loss of perishable inventory, and deters potential investors. Eskom's challenges are compounded by its reliance on coal, which accounts for around 80% of South Africa's electricity generation. Depleting coal reserves and environmental regulations have made it increasingly difficult for Eskom to maintain supply. The transition to renewable energy has been slow, hindered by bureaucratic inertia and a lack of investment. Even when renewable energy is generated, its intermittency means it cannot replace the consistent power supply needed to alleviate load shedding. Furthermore, Eskom's power plants require constant maintenance, leading to frequent breakdowns and further exacerbating the situation. In 2023, the frequency and severity of load shedding have surged, with some regions experiencing power cuts for up to 10 hours a day. The energy crisis has also become a political football. Opposition parties criticize the ruling African National Congress (ANC) for its handling of Eskom, while labor unions use the threat of strikes to extract concessions. Meanwhile, criminals and saboteurs target power infrastructure, further disrupting supply. The situation reached a new low in 2022 when a series of breakdowns at multiple power stations forced the reinstatement of severe load shedding measures during the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite temporary relief measures, the underlying issues remain unresolved, leaving South Africa's energy future uncertain.

Economic Instability and the Shadow of Corruption

The energy crisis in South Africa is deeply intertwined with the country's economic instability, creating a vicious cycle that threatens to push the nation toward collapse. At the heart of this crisis lies corruption, a pervasive issue that has plagued South Africa since the apartheid era and has been exacerbated by lax enforcement of anti-corruption laws. Under President Jacob Zuma's tenure from 2009 to 2018, corruption reached new heights, coinciding with a critical window during which the energy crisis could have been addressed. Instead, the state-owned utility Eskom became a hotbed of corruption, with scandals dating back to 2008 and intensifying during and after the COVID-19 pandemic. Eskom's woes are manifold. Employees have been implicated in taking bribes to sabotage facilities or facilitate theft, while officials have misrepresented the quality of coal used in power plants. External actors, particularly repair companies, have orchestrated the theft of power plant components to create repair opportunities. Andre de Ruyter, Eskom's former CEO, alleged that the company is deeply infiltrated by criminal syndicates, with high-level officials involved, and that corruption costs Eskom over $50 million annually. The construction of Medupi and Kusile power plants, completed in 2021 and 2023 respectively, was marred by corruption, further straining Eskom's finances and operational capabilities. Acts of sabotage are disturbingly common, with essential components such as steel supports, cables, and fuel supplies frequently targeted. Each incident of sabotage exacerbates the load-shedding problem, pushing the country closer to the brink of economic and social unrest. The frequent and unpredictable power cuts have devastating consequences for the most vulnerable populations, particularly those reliant on public healthcare. South Africa's public healthcare system is already critically underfunded, understaffed, and overworked, with shortages of essential equipment and medicine. Private and university hospitals offer better care but are inaccessible to most of the population. The energy crisis compounds these issues, forcing hospitals to endure extended power outages. Emergency generators, while crucial, are expensive and not always reliable. Patients in operating theaters and neonatal intensive care units are at high risk, as are vaccines and medicines that require refrigeration. The food sector faces similar challenges. Intermittent power supply disrupts cold storage and processing facilities, leading to food spoilage and shortages. This, in turn, drives up prices and exacerbates food insecurity, particularly in poorer communities. The economic fallout is severe, with rising debt, increased unemployment, and a shrinking GDP. The World Bank reported in 2022 that South Africa's GDP growth rate was stagnant, while unemployment hovered around 35%, with youth unemployment exceeding 60%. The energy crisis, coupled with rampant corruption, has pushed the economy to the edge, with many analysts warning of imminent collapse if drastic measures are not taken. The government's attempts to address the crisis have been hampered by political infighting and a lack of coherent policy, further deepening the sense of despair among the populace.

Crime and Social Unrest: The Human Cost of Collapse

The energy crisis in South Africa has catalysed a surge in crime and social unrest, exacerbating the country's already dire security situation. The pervasive power outages, known as loadshedding, have created an environment ripe for criminal activity. Electric fences, alarm systems, and security lighting—all critical components of urban and suburban security—are rendered ineffective during outages. This vulnerability has led to a spike in break-ins, burglaries, larceny, and looting. Statistics from the South African Police Service (SAPS) reveal a disturbing trend: in the first quarter of 2023, reported burglaries increased by 15% compared to the same period in 2022, with many incidents occurring during scheduled power cuts. The city of Johannesburg, often dubbed the 'Crime Capital of the World,' has seen a particularly alarming rise in criminal activities during these periods of darkness. The impact of loadshedding on law enforcement is equally concerning. Police response times have significantly increased due to traffic congestion caused by non-functional traffic lights. In Durban, for instance, response times to emergency calls have doubled during peak loadshedding hours. This delay in response not only emboldens criminals but also leaves victims more vulnerable. The SAPS has had to adapt, deploying more officers on foot patrols during outages, but this is a stopgap measure at best. The strain on resources is evident, with many police stations themselves affected by power cuts, leading to disruptions in communication and operational capabilities. Beyond conventional crime, political violence has also surged. Protests, often sparked by economic grievances and service delivery failures, have turned violent with alarming frequency. In July 2023, protests in Cape Town escalated into riots, with demonstrators setting fire to municipal buildings and clashing with police. The underlying issues are complex, but the immediate trigger was often the inability of local governments to maintain essential services due to power outages. The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), a prominent opposition party, has capitalized on this unrest, organizing protests that often devolve into violence. The ruling African National Congress (ANC) has struggled to maintain order, with internal divisions further complicating the situation. The economic instability compounded by loadshedding has created a perfect storm for social unrest. Unemployment rates hover around 33%, with youth unemployment even higher. Many small businesses, the backbone of South Africa's economy, have been forced to close or scale back operations due to unreliable power supply. In Soweto, a township in Johannesburg, numerous spaza shops (informal convenience stores) have shut down, leaving residents with fewer economic opportunities and increased desperation. The Central Bank of South Africa estimates that loadshedding costs the economy $13 billion annually, further stifling growth and exacerbating poverty. The human cost of this collapse is immense. Food security has deteriorated, with perishable goods spoiling en masse due to lack of refrigeration. Livestock die-offs in enclosed farms have become common, further straining the food supply. Even access to clean water is threatened, as power outages affect water pumping and sewage treatment. In February 2023, residents of Pretoria faced severe water shortages, with taps running dry for days. The health implications are dire, with waterborne diseases on the rise. The United Nations has warned that South Africa is on the brink of a humanitarian crisis, with millions at risk of starvation and water scarcity. The government's response has been inadequate, with promises of relief often unfulfilled. The situation demands urgent and decisive action, but the political will and institutional capacity to address these challenges seem lacking.

The ANC's Fading Grip on Power: A Shifting Political Landscape

When trying to figure out just what all this means for South Africa, there’s one clear, and uncomfortable reality to start with: South Africa is rolling into election season. These elections, held in 2024, will contest all 400 seats of the South African National Assembly, where the African National Congress, ANC, led by South African President Cyril Ramaphosa, has held a controlling influence for the vast majority of the country’s post-apartheid history. But in 2021’s municipal elections, the ANC suffered a warning shot across the bow, with the party receiving fewer votes than ever and suffering a significant, ongoing hit to approval ratings. Now, it would be premature to declare that the ANC is on its last legs; the party still has a good chance to receive a plurality, or even a majority of votes in the 2024 elections. But with the nation’s many opposition parties conspiring more closely than ever to form a coalition, there’s also a fair chance that the ANC, even with help from other parties, will have trouble getting the majority it needs to govern. Perhaps the worst possible outcome, is one that would take a page from the aftermath of the United States’ 2020 presidential election, or the 2023 riots that took place in Brazil after president Jair Bolsonaro was voted out of office. Under such pressure from the blackouts, and from the many, many issues that follow on from them, it’s not inconceivable that a close or conspiracy-fueled election cycle could be the spark to set off the whole powder keg. Luckily for South Africa, the nation was able to weather its difficult winter season without complete collapse this year, with a reminder to our Northern Hemisphere viewers that May, June, July, and August are the coldest months of their year, not the warmest. But just because South Africa survived this year, doesn’t meant that it’ll have as easy a time in the next go-around, and with the date for the 2024 elections not yet set, as of the writing of this video, there’s a real threat that continued deterioration in the country will produce an even worse winter right before, or even during, the election season. Then, there’s the international side of the issue, where South Africa’s predicament has wide-reaching ramifications both for the country itself, and the entirety of sub-Saharan Africa. Of course, the nations that rely on South Africa for their own electricity, including Zimbabwe, Mozambique, Eswatani, and others, suffer chronic power cuts and shortages as well. We don’t want to undersell the serious impact of those measures, on those nations, even if the political problems that come from them are somewhat further-removed from South African politics. But potentially the much larger issue, in a geopolitical sense, is how South Africa’s energy crisis can be used as leverage by power players in the global community. China is the nation that appears most interested in being South Africa’s lifeline. On August 23 of this year, South Africa signed a massive infrastructural overhaul agreement with China as part of the country’s BRICS Summit, also attended by India, Russia, and Brazil. The deal would not only upgrade the nation’s transmission and distribution systems, but bring much-needed expertise in renewable energy plant construction, and extend the life of the nation’s existing coal-fired power plants for as long as possible before an inevitable retirement. Add to that a series of grants and emergency power sources, and China’s resources, which South Africa has now accepted, are the sort of offer that a country in this position simply can’t refuse.

The Perfect Storm: How South Africa's Challenges Intersect

South Africa's myriad challenges do not exist in isolation; rather, they intersect and exacerbate one another, creating a perfect storm that threatens the nation's stability. At the heart of this storm lies the energy crisis, which has far-reaching implications for the economy and society at large. Eskom, the state-owned electricity utility, has been plagued by corruption, mismanagement, and aging infrastructure, leading to chronic power outages known as load shedding. These outages have crippled industries, stifled economic growth, and fueled social unrest. The South African economy, already struggling with high unemployment and inequality, has been dealt a severe blow by the energy crisis. The mining sector, a critical component of the economy, has been particularly hard hit. Mines require substantial energy, and the frequent power outages have led to decreased productivity and increased costs. For instance, the gold mining industry, which employs hundreds of thousands of people, has seen a significant decline in output due to unreliable electricity supply. The economic instability has, in turn, exacerbated social tensions. Unemployment rates, particularly among the youth, have soared, leading to increased crime and social unrest. Protests and strikes have become commonplace, further straining the already fragile social fabric. The government's response to these challenges has been largely ineffective. President Cyril Ramaphosa's administration has introduced several initiatives aimed at addressing the energy crisis, including the declaration of a state of emergency and the mobilization of the military to protect energy infrastructure. However, these measures have had limited impact. The administration has also opened the door to private energy developments, emphasizing renewable energy sources. Yet, the transition to renewable energy is a long-term process that requires significant investment and infrastructure development. South Africa has pledged to phase out twelve gigawatts of coal power and replace it with eighteen gigawatts of renewable energy by 2030. However, this transition is fraught with challenges, including the need for substantial foreign investment and the development of new infrastructure. The global geopolitical landscape has added another layer of complexity to South Africa's challenges. China, seeking to expand its influence in Africa, has emerged as a major player in South Africa's energy sector. China has invested heavily in South Africa, providing much-needed financial aid and infrastructure development. This contrasts sharply with the conditional support offered by the United States and Europe, which have been more focused on promoting renewable energy. China's willingness to provide immediate, unconditional support has made it an attractive partner for South Africa, despite concerns about the long-term implications of increased Chinese influence. The intersection of these challenges has created a precarious situation for South Africa. The energy crisis, economic instability, and social unrest are interconnected, each exacerbating the others. The government's efforts to address these challenges have been hampered by a legacy of corruption and infrastructural inadequacy. As South Africa navigates this perfect storm, the path forward remains uncertain. The country faces a critical juncture, where the decisions made today will shape its future for decades to come.

Implications of Collapse: Regional and Global Consequences

The potential collapse of South Africa's power grid and economy would send shockwaves through the region and the global economy. Regionally, South Africa's instability would exacerbate existing tensions and crises. The Southern African Development Community (SADC) would face increased pressure to intervene or mediate, stretching its limited resources. Neighboring countries like Mozambique, already grappling with insurgencies, and Zimbabwe, mired in economic stagnation, would struggle to absorb potential refugees or maintain their own security. South Africa's collapse could reignite old conflicts, such as those between various ethnic groups and political factions, drawing in regional actors. The Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), with its rich mineral resources and ongoing conflicts, could see an influx of South African mercenaries or militia groups, further destabilizing the region. The United Nations and African Union would likely need to deploy peacekeeping missions, but their effectiveness would depend on international support and resources. South Africa's economic collapse would have global repercussions. As a member of BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa), a significant trade bloc, South Africa's woes would ripple through global markets. South Africa is a net exporter of electricity to neighboring countries, and its collapse would force these nations to find alternative energy sources, potentially disrupting their economies. Globally, South Africa is a significant exporter of platinum, gold, and other minerals crucial for various industries, including technology and automotive manufacturing. Disruptions in these supply chains would drive up commodity prices and affect global production. South Africa's strengthening ties with China and Russia add another layer of complexity. China, already a significant investor in South Africa, might increase its influence, leading to a more prominent Chinese presence in the region. This could exacerbate tensions with Western powers, who might view China's increased influence as a threat to their interests. Russia, eager to circumvent Western sanctions, might exploit South Africa's vulnerability to expand its foothold in Africa. This could lead to increased military cooperation, with Russia providing arms and training in exchange for access to South African resources and markets. Such a scenario would complicate regional geopolitics and potentially draw in other global powers. A full-scale collapse, akin to Venezuela's 2019 economic meltdown, could have catastrophic consequences. Venezuela's crisis, precipitated by an energy collapse, led to weeks of continuous power outages, soaring crime rates, and mass emigration. South Africa, with its high crime rates and endemic corruption, could face similar or worse outcomes. Continuous power outages would fuel looting and public unrest, overwhelming law enforcement and further destabilizing the country. The South African National Defence Force (SANDF), already stretched thin, might struggle to maintain order, potentially leading to a breakdown of state authority. In such a scenario, foreign intervention, whether humanitarian or military, would be inevitable, but its success would depend on addressing the root causes of the collapse and fostering a sustainable recovery.

A Crossroads for South Africa: Can Stability Be Restored?

At that same time, the South African government may choose repressive means to keep order rather than collaborative ones, especially in the event of either the African National Congress or an opposition coalition getting a shaky or even illegitimate hold on power. The country’s water supply and sanitation, already highly questionable, would likely go down the tubes, and as emergency generators run out of fuel, hospitals, morgues, and food stores are likely to suffer catastrophic failure. South Africa’s telecommunications systems, just as reliant as anything on Eskom’s power supply, would likely become inoperable, and according to Eskom’s own estimates, their power grid could take as long as two weeks to restore. What that means, and how it would be dealt with, we can’t say, but we’ve got to stress that those immediate effects aren’t just hypothetical. At present, South Africa’s energy situation is such that the only reason why water and food haven’t become unavailable, why civil unrest hasn’t taken over, and why hospitals can keep the lights on, are the limited infusions of electricity that Eskom can supply. Take those away, and South Africa will descend into chaos. Perhaps that chaos is temporary, and power, then centralized authority, is restored in short order; perhaps it would necessitate boots on the ground from China, from the surrounding nations, or even from the West, to lock down the pandemonium. Or, perhaps it leads to civil war, in a relatively well-off nation that nonetheless remains deeply divided across society. No matter the eventual outcome, it’s clear to see that South Africa is in dire straits—not necessarily doomed for an impending collapse, but not particularly far off from it, either. The future of the nation is being decided as we speak, by Eskom, by those in South Africa and around the world who continue to search for alternatives, and by those South African citizens who will soon have to choose who, if anybody, is best suited to lead their nation away from ruin. For our part, we certainly hope that this crisis comes to a resolution soon, and one that leaves both South Africa, and the millions of people who live there, looking toward a brighter future than what seems to exist today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will South Africa be safe from World War III?

See the full article for details on Will South Africa be safe.

What will happen on 27 September 2025 in South Africa?

See the full article for details on What will happen on 27.

Is it safe for Americans to go to South Africa right now?

See the full article for details on Is it safe for Americans.

Is there trouble in South Africa?

See the full article for details on Is there trouble in South.

How safe is South Africa if WW3 happens?

See the full article for details on How safe is South Africa.

Related Coverage

Sources

About the Author

Jackson Reed

Jackson Reed creates and presents analysis focused on military doctrine, strategic competition, and conflict dynamics.

About the Team →